What Is Mystery Shopping and How Does It Work?

Written by Support EXP

Key Takeaways:

A well-designed mystery shopping program should have clear objectives, detailed guidelines, objective evaluation criteria, timely feedback, actionable reports, and realistic scenarios that reflect the typical customer experience.
By using mystery shoppers to assess various aspects of their business, such as employee behavior, adherence to company policies, and service quality, companies can gather valuable insights and identify areas for improvement.
Leveraging insights from mystery shopping, companies can optimize their operations, strengthen their customer relationships, and ultimately drive business success in a competitive market.

Introduction

Mystery shopping is a research method that businesses use to assess and improve their customer service and overall customer experience.

It involves recruiting people, known as “shoppers,” to perform regular transactions with a business, then submit their evaluations of the experience based on established standards and expectations.

This article explores the definition of mystery shopping, its different types, the qualities of a good mystery shopping program, and the reasons why financial institutions use mystery shopping.

It also discusses the benefits that mystery shopping can bring to companies, such as identifying areas for improvement, ensuring customer service standards are upheld, and enhancing staff training and performance.

By gaining valuable insights from mystery shopping, organizations can take strategic actions to enhance their customer service and build lasting customer relationships.

What is the Customer Journey?

Definition of Mystery Shopping

Mystery shopping, also known as secret shopping, is a research and evaluation method used by companies to assess and analyze the quality of customer service and the overall customer experience.

It involves recruiting individuals, known as mystery shoppers, who pose as regular customers and visit a specific store, branch, restaurant, hotel, or any other business to evaluate various aspects of the service provided.

The mystery shopper’s primary role is to act as a typical customer, observing and interacting with the staff, making inquiries, purchasing products or services, and sometimes even lodging complaints or providing feedback. They are typically given a set of instructions or specific criteria to evaluate, such as employee behavior, cleanliness, product knowledge, adherence to company policies, speed of service, and other factors that contribute to customer satisfaction.

After completing their visit, mystery shoppers usually provide detailed feedback, either through a written report or an online survey, highlighting their observations, interactions, and overall experience. This feedback helps businesses identify areas for improvement, train their staff, and enhance the customer experience to meet or exceed customer expectations.

Mystery shopping plays a significant role in quality control, customer service evaluation, and enhancement of operational standards in various industries.

Different Types of Mystery Shopping

There are various types of mystery shopping, each tailored to specific industries or objectives. Here are some common types:

1. In-person Mystery Shopping

This is the traditional form of mystery shopping where a shopper visits a physical location, such as a retail store, branch, restaurant, or hotel, to assess the customer experience. They observe factors like store cleanliness, employee behavior, product availability, and adherence to company standards.

2. Telephone Mystery Shopping

In this type, mystery shoppers make phone calls to businesses to evaluate customer service over the phone. They may assess factors like the speed of response, professionalism, product knowledge, and the ability to handle inquiries or complaints.

3. Online Mystery Shopping

With the rise of e-commerce, online mystery shopping has become increasingly popular. Shoppers evaluate the customer experience on websites, online marketplaces, or social media platforms. They may assess factors like website usability, product descriptions, ease of navigation, checkout process, and responsiveness of customer support.

4. Mobile Mystery Shopping

This type of mystery shopping utilizes mobile devices to assess the customer experience. Shoppers may use specific mobile apps or access mobile websites to evaluate factors like app performance, user interface, ease of use, and overall satisfaction with mobile services.

5. Video Mystery Shopping

Shoppers use hidden cameras or mobile devices to record their shopping experiences. This type allows companies to review the recorded footage to gain insights into customer interactions, store layout, visual merchandising, and employee behavior.

6. Compliance Mystery Shopping

This type focuses on evaluating adherence to legal and regulatory requirements. Mystery shoppers assess whether businesses comply with specific laws, industry standards, or company policies. It can be particularly useful in industries such as finance, healthcare, or food service.

7. Competitor Mystery Shopping

Companies use this type of mystery shopping to gather intelligence about their competitors. Mystery shoppers visit rival businesses to assess their products, services, pricing, customer experience, and overall strategies.

These are just a few examples of the types of mystery shopping that exist. Depending on the industry and specific research objectives, companies may also customize mystery shopping programs to suit their needs.

Qualities of a Good Mystery Shopping Program

All mystery shopping programs are not created equal! A good mystery shopping program possesses several key qualities that contribute to its effectiveness. Here are some important qualities of a good mystery shopping program:

1. Clear Objectives

The program should have well-defined objectives and specific goals that align with the organization’s overall strategy. The objectives should be communicated clearly to the mystery shoppers so they understand what they need to evaluate.

2. Detailed Guidelines

The program should provide detailed guidelines to the mystery shoppers, specifying the tasks they need to perform, the behaviors they should observe, and the information they need to collect during the shopping experience. Clear guidelines help ensure consistency in evaluations and accurate data collection.

3. Realistic Scenarios

The mystery shopping program should create realistic scenarios that reflect the typical customer experience. The scenarios should cover a range of interactions and touchpoints, such as phone calls, in-person visits, online interactions, and any other relevant channels.

4. Effective Training

Mystery shoppers should receive thorough training before they start evaluating. The training should cover the program’s objectives, guidelines, evaluation criteria, and reporting requirements. It should also provide guidance on professionalism, ethical conduct, and the importance of maintaining objectivity.

5. Objective Evaluation Criteria

The program should establish clear and objective evaluation criteria to assess various aspects of the customer experience, such as employee behavior, service quality, product knowledge, cleanliness, and adherence to company policies. The criteria should be measurable and standardized to ensure consistency across evaluations.

6. Timely Feedback

A good mystery shopping program provides timely feedback to the employees being evaluated. This feedback allows the organization to address any identified issues promptly and provide coaching or training to its employees.

7. Actionable Reports

The program should generate comprehensive and actionable reports based on the mystery shoppers’ evaluations. These reports should clearly communicate the findings, highlight areas of strength and needed improvement, and provide specific recommendations for enhancing the customer experience.

8. Continuous Improvement

A good mystery shopping program is not a one-time effort but an ongoing process. It should incorporate feedback to continuously improve the program and address evolving business needs.

9. Confidentiality and Anonymity

Mystery shoppers’ identities should be kept confidential to maintain the integrity of the program. Anonymity allows mystery shoppers to observe and evaluate the customer experience without any bias or influence from the employees being evaluated.

10. Collaboration and Communication

The program should foster open communication and collaboration between the organization, mystery shoppers, and employees. This collaboration helps clarify expectations, address any concerns or questions, and build a partnership for improving the customer experience.

By incorporating these qualities into a mystery shopping program, organizations can gain valuable insights into their customer experience, identify areas for improvement, and enhance their overall service quality.

Why Do Financial Institutions Use Mystery Shopping?

Financial institutions use mystery shopping as a valuable tool for evaluating and improving their customer service and overall customer experience. The collection and analysis of real-time customer feedback helps banks and credit unions understand their customers.

Here some of the specific reasons why financial institutions employ mystery shopping:

1. Customer Service Evaluation

Mystery shopping allows financial institutions to assess how their employees interact with customers. By sending in undercover shoppers who pose as regular customers, they can evaluate the quality of service provided, including factors such as friendliness, knowledge, responsiveness, and adherence to company policies.

2. Compliance Monitoring

Financial institutions must comply with various regulations and internal policies. Mystery shopping helps ensure that employees are following these guidelines, such as verifying that proper procedures are being followed for account opening, loan applications, or any other relevant processes.

3. Training and Development

Mystery shopping provides valuable feedback that can be used for employee training and development purposes. Identifying areas where employees may require additional training or coaching helps improve their skills and enhances overall customer satisfaction.

4. Identifying Operational Issues

Mystery shoppers can uncover operational issues that may go unnoticed by management. This could include long wait times, inefficient processes, broken equipment, or other factors that hinder the smooth functioning of the institution.

5. Competitive Analysis/Benchmarking

Mystery shopping allows financial institutions to compare their customer service against competitors in the industry. By evaluating their own performance in comparison to others, they can identify areas of improvement and implement best practices.

6. Brand Consistency

Financial institutions often have multiple branches or locations. Mystery shopping helps ensure that the customer experience remains consistent across all branches, maintaining brand reputation and customer satisfaction.

7. Performance Incentives

Mystery shopping results can be used as a basis for performance evaluation and incentive programs. Employees who consistently deliver exceptional customer service can be recognized and rewarded accordingly.

An effective mystery shopping program provides financial institutions with insights into the customer experience, helps identify areas for improvement, and contributes to enhancing their service quality and operational efficiency.

How Can Mystery Shopping Benefit My Company?

Ensures Procedures and Processes Are Followed

Mystery shoppers are typically provided with specific guidelines, checklists, or evaluation forms that outline the procedures and processes that should be followed. These guidelines can include criteria such as employee greetings, product knowledge, service quality, adherence to sales scripts, cleanliness standards, or response time.

By objectively assessing the employees’ performance against these criteria, mystery shoppers can identify any deviations or areas where improvements are needed.

Ensures Customer Service Standards Are Upheld

Mystery shoppers provide an objective perspective on the customer experience. They assess various aspects such as employee behavior, product knowledge, response time, cleanliness, and adherence to company policies. By observing these elements, mystery shoppers can identify gaps or areas where customer service standards may not be met.

When deficiencies are identified, companies can provide targeted training programs to address any gaps in customer service skills or product knowledge. This helps employees improve their performance and enhances overall customer service standards.

Ensuring Cross Selling, Upselling and Attempts to Further the Customer Journey Are Taken

When designing a mystery shopping program, companies can include specific criteria related to cross-selling, upselling, and customer journey enhancements. This can involve providing mystery shoppers with scenarios or specific products/services to inquire about, assess the staff’s ability to suggest additional items, or evaluate how well the customer journey is facilitated.

Ensures Staff Training Is Implemented and Effective

Conclusion

Mystery shopping serves as a powerful tool for companies across various industries to evaluate and improve their customer service and overall customer experience. By employing mystery shoppers to assess different aspects of their business, financial institutions can gather valuable insights, identify areas for improvement, and enhance their service quality.

The clear objectives, detailed guidelines, realistic scenarios, and objective evaluation criteria of a well-designed mystery shopping program contribute to its effectiveness.

Moreover, timely feedback, actionable reports, and a commitment to continuous improvement ensure that financial institutions can make data-driven decisions and address evolving customer needs.

By leveraging the benefits of mystery shopping, banks and credit unions can optimize their operations, strengthen their brand reputation, and foster long-term customer loyalty in today’s competitive marketplace.

If you’re ready to learn more about implementing your own mystery shop program, reach out to one of our CX experts today!

Have More Questions? Reach Out to Our Team Of Experts

Net Promoter®, NPS®, NPS Prism®, and the NPS-related emoticons are registered trademarks of Bain & Company, Inc., Satmetrix Systems, Inc., and Fred Reichheld.