Mystery Shopping Examples to Improve Your Banking Experience
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways:
- Mystery shopping in the banking industry can strengthen brand promise, improve the customer journey, and enhance employee training while providing insights into competitive analysis and operational efficiency.
- By utilizing mystery shoppers, financial institutions can identify gaps in employee training, benchmark against competitors, and collect valuable data to enhance the customer experience.
- Mystery shopping reveals the real customer experience, helps evaluate touchpoints in the customer journey, and enables financial institutions to take targeted actions for improvement based on feedback and analysis.
Introduction
By reviewing real-world examples of mystery shopping, you can improve your banking experience by strengthening brand consistency, building loyalty, and staying competitive in the financial industry.
This article shows how financial institutions leverage mystery shopping to bolster customer satisfaction, foster loyalty, and ultimately elevate their position in the ever-evolving marketplace of consumer banking.
Mystery shopping evaluates — in objective terms — the process of delivering consistent, accurate and professional customer experiences. If designed and implemented properly, mystery shopping can deliver significant real-world benefits to financial institutions. What does a mystery shopping program look like in action? Keep reading!
Benefits of Mystery Shopping
Evaluation of the Implementation of Branding and Customer Journey
Here’s an example of how mystery shopping can evaluate the implementation of a bank’s branding and the customer journey:
Steps in the Process
- Planning: A bank decides to conduct mystery shopping evaluations to ensure that its service is consistent with its brand standard and that customers are having positive experiences when they conduct their business. Bank leaders define specific criteria to evaluate, such as staff behavior, branch appearance, service offerings, and overall customer interactions.
- Selecting Mystery Shoppers: The bank selects mystery shoppers who will visit the bank branch or other channel and provide detailed feedback on their experience.
- Creating Scenarios: Each mystery shopper is given an assignment to conduct. For instance, a mystery shopper might be instructed to inquire about opening a new savings account or to ask questions about online banking services.
- Conducting Visits: The mystery shopper visits the bank, discreetly engaging with staff to conduct the assigned transaction.
Evaluating the Customer Journey
- Information Gathering: The shopper assesses the process of gathering customer information and needs. Does the bank employee ask relevant questions to understand the customer’s situation?
- Service and Communication: The shopper notes how well the employee explains various products and services, addresses questions, and provides relevant information.
- Wait Time: The shopper observes the time it takes to complete the transaction. Is the wait time reasonable, and does the employee keep them informed about any delays?
- Providing Feedback: After each visit, mystery shoppers compile their observations and experiences into detailed reports. These reports include both positive aspects of the customer journey and any areas for improvement. The reports are then submitted to the bank’s management team.
- Analysis and Action: The bank’s management team reviews the mystery shopping reports to identify patterns and insights. They use the feedback to make informed decisions about training, process improvements, and adjustments to enhance the customer experience.
- Continuous Improvement: By conducting regular mystery shopping evaluations, the bank can track improvements over time, identify ongoing challenges, and ensure that customer journey remains aligned with customer expectations and the bank’s brand promise.
Identify Gaps in Employee Training
Here’s an example of how mystery shopping can be used to identify gaps in bank employee training:
Steps
- Setting the Parameters: The bank defines specific criteria that reflect their desired level of customer service. These criteria could include things like greeting customers upon entry, explaining various account options, offering assistance with transactions, handling customer inquiries, and providing a friendly and professional demeanor.
- Creating a Mystery Shopper Profile: The bank selects mystery shoppers who fit the profile of potential customers. These shoppers should appear as regular customers seeking various services from the bank.
- Developing Scenarios: The bank designs different scenarios for the mystery shoppers to follow. For example, a mystery shopper might be tasked with opening a new account, inquiring about a loan, or simply conducting a routine transaction.
- Conducting Visits: The mystery shoppers visit different branches or channels at various times, posing as ordinary customers. They interact with the bank employees and take note of their experiences.
- Documentation: The mystery shoppers document their interactions with bank employees, paying close attention to how well employees adhere to the predefined criteria. They make note of things like whether the employee greeted them, how well they explained services, their knowledge about different products, the clarity of their responses, and their overall demeanor.
- Evaluation: After the mystery shopping visits are completed, the collected data and observations are compiled and analyzed. This includes identifying common patterns and trends in employee behavior across different branches and situations.
- Identifying Gaps: Through analysis, the bank’s management can identify areas where employees consistently fall short of meeting the established customer service criteria. For example, they might discover that employees struggle with explaining certain complex financial products or that there’s inconsistency in how inquiries are handled.
- Training and Improvement: Armed with the insights from the mystery shopping evaluations, the bank’s HR and training teams can design targeted training programs to address the identified gaps. This could involve providing additional training on specific products, improving communication skills, or enhancing overall customer interaction techniques.
- Follow-Up Mystery Shopping: After implementing the training programs, the bank can conduct follow-up mystery shopping visits to assess whether the identified gaps have been successfully addressed and if the overall customer service experience has improved.
Benefits
- Objective Assessment: Mystery shopping provides an objective and unbiased assessment of customer service, as employees are unaware that they are being evaluated.
- Actionable Insights: The insights gained from mystery shopping allow banks to tailor training programs specifically to address the identified weaknesses.
- Consistency: By identifying and rectifying training gaps, the bank can ensure a consistent level of customer service across all branches.
- Customer Satisfaction: Improved employee training results in enhanced customer satisfaction and loyalty, ultimately benefiting the bank’s reputation and business success.
Mystery Shoppers Reveal the Real Customer Experience
What Branding and Messaging Are Your Customers Exposed To?
Imagine that a bank, let’s call it “TruBank,” is interested in evaluating its customer experience and ensuring that its branding and messaging are consistent and effective across its various branches. To achieve this, they decide to conduct mystery shopping visits.
When mystery shoppers visit different TruBank branches, they pay close attention to how well bank representatives convey the bank’s messaging, values, and unique selling points.
Mystery shoppers rate their interactions with bank representatives, considering factors like friendliness, professionalism, and accuracy of information provided. They also note any discrepancies between the service received in the branch and what they’ve encountered through other channels.
TruBank gathers the mystery shopping reports and analyzes the findings. They identify trends, common issues, and areas of improvement. This analysis allows TruBank to make informed decisions about refining their branding, messaging, and customer service training.
Based on the insights gained from mystery shopping, TruBank can initiate targeted improvements. This might involve updating training materials for bank representatives, ensuring consistent branding materials across branches, and addressing any discrepancies between messaging channels.
TruBank continues to conduct regular mystery shopping visits to monitor their progress over time and ensure that the desired changes have been implemented effectively.
By leveraging mystery shopping, TruBank gains valuable insights into how their brand is perceived by customers. This helps them enhance their customer experience and maintain consistent messaging across their branches.
What Are the Touchpoints in Their Journey?
Touchpoints are the different stages or points of contact a customer has with a business, such as a physical branch, website, call center, or social media platform. Here’s how mystery shopping can help evaluate these touchpoints:
Planning
Pre-purchase Interactions
Purchase Process
Overall Experience
Evaluate Employee Training, Orientations, and Procedures with Mystery Shopper Reports
Identify Training Needs
Mystery shopping can reveal gaps in employees’ skills and competencies. For instance, if employees struggle with upselling or cross-selling techniques, handling difficult customers, or resolving complaints effectively, mystery shopping evaluations can highlight these areas for improvement. Training programs can then be designed to address these skill gaps.
Mystery shopping helps assess the consistency of service delivery across multiple touchpoints. If employees in different departments or locations are providing inconsistent service experiences, it indicates a need for standardized training to ensure a consistent level of service throughout the organization.
By analyzing the data collected from mystery shopping evaluations, organizations can identify recurring issues, knowledge gaps, skill deficiencies, or areas where employees require additional training. This information can be used to design targeted training programs, workshops, or coaching sessions to enhance employee performance and improve the overall customer experience.
Uncover Areas of Opportunity for Upselling
Mystery shoppers assess the knowledge and familiarity of employees with different products or services. If employees possess a thorough understanding of offerings, they can confidently present upselling opportunities to customers and provide relevant recommendations.
Mystery shoppers pay attention to suggestive selling techniques employed by employees. This involves assessing whether employees actively offer complementary items or highlight premium options that align with the customer’s needs and preferences, providing opportunities for upselling.
If employees actively listen to customers, understand their needs, and tailor their recommendations accordingly, it creates opportunities to upsell by offering more relevant and valuable products or services. Through a personalized approach, selling becomes a natural extension of the customer relationship. Because it doesn’t come across as forced, the customer is more likely to be receptive.
Improve Customer Loyalty
By identifying areas that need improvement, mystery shopping helps businesses promptly address issues that can turn customers away. When customers see improvements in the areas that matter to them, they are more likely to become loyal and repeat buyers.
By assessing factors like responsiveness, friendliness, and knowledge of the staff, mystery shopping helps companies identify gaps between service delivery and customer expectations. They can then train their employees in the service skills needed to close those gaps. Consistently delivering exceptional customer service creates a positive impression and fosters loyalty within customers.
Using Mystery Shopping for Competitive Comparison and Analysis
Identify Key Differentiators
From analysis of shopper feedback, organizations can identify the factors that consistently stand out as key differentiators. These could be aspects that mystery shoppers consistently praise or areas where your business outperforms competitors. Look for unique selling points that can be leveraged to differentiate your business in the market.
Once you have identified the key differentiators, develop action plans to enhance and leverage them further. For areas that need improvement, create strategies to address any shortcomings and ensure consistent delivery of exceptional customer experiences.
Use a Mystery Shopper to Collect Real-Time Data Across Various Touchpoints
Identify Your Status Quo
Mystery shopping provides a valuable tool for businesses to gain a comprehensive understanding of their current status quo. It helps identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement, allowing businesses to make data-driven decisions to enhance their operations and deliver a better customer experience.
Mystery shoppers assess the customer experience by evaluating factors such as employee behavior, product knowledge, responsiveness, cleanliness, and overall satisfaction. By experiencing the business firsthand, mystery shoppers can provide unbiased feedback on the current state of customer service and identify areas that need improvement.
Factor Results Into Staff Evaluations and Performance Reviews
Use the mystery shopping results to set performance goals for individual employees. These goals should be specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). For example, if a staff member receives consistently low ratings in product knowledge, the goal might be to improve their knowledge by attending training sessions or studying relevant materials.
Provide feedback and coaching by scheduling regular performance review meetings with employees to discuss their mystery shopping results. Share both positive feedback and areas for improvement, and provide specific examples from the mystery shopping evaluations. Offer guidance, support, and resources to help employees develop the necessary skills to enhance their performance.
Collaborate with employees to create action plans that outline steps to improve their performance based on the feedback received from mystery shopping evaluations. These plans should include specific milestones, training opportunities, and timelines for improvement.
As an alternative to manager-based coaching using member feedback data, self-directed learning can encourage frontline employees to take accountability for their own professional development. An effective self-directed learning program will equip each employee with the personalized feedback he or she needs to develop precisely those skills that can have the greatest impact on their performance.
Finally, regularly review and monitor employees’ progress towards their performance goals. Provide ongoing support, coaching, and feedback to ensure they are on track and making the necessary improvements.
Mystery shopping can be a powerful tool for improving the customer experience you deliver to your customers. If you’re ready to find out what a mystery shop program can do to elevate your bank or credit union’s experience, reach out to one of our CX experts today!
Have More Questions? Reach Out to Our Team Of Experts
Net Promoter®, NPS®, NPS Prism®, and the NPS-related emoticons are registered trademarks of Bain & Company, Inc., Satmetrix Systems, Inc., and Fred Reichheld.