Support EXP -
A First Class Mystery Shopping Company

Written by Support EXP
Support EXP Logo

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways: 

  • Support EXP’s first-class mystery shopping program builds skills and improves frontline performance by equipping your own customers to evaluate their experiences across all channels.
  • By addressing service gaps, meeting customer expectations, and enhancing communication and employee performance, financial institutions use Support EXP mystery shopping to foster stronger connections with their customers, leading to increased customer loyalty and business growth.
  • A well-designed and properly implemented mystery shopping program provides a proven and sophisticated process of leveraging the Voice of Your Customers to ensure that employee service and sales skills are learned, put into practice, and ingrained, reflecting true cultural transformation.

Introduction

Mystery shopping, done well, promotes customer-centric service that can differentiate an organization. A first-class mystery shopping company like Support EXP can help financial institutions understand customer experiences from an unbiased perspective.

These FIs can then improve the skills of those on the front lines to better meet the expectations of their customers, fostering stronger relationships and engendering trust and loyalty.

Benefits of Mystery Shopping

Data Collection via Customer Journey

Mystery shopping provides valuable data by employing discreet, trained evaluators to interact with a business. As they navigate through the customer journey, mystery shoppers assess critical touchpoints such as website usability, product displays, staff engagement, service efficiency, and complaint handling.

By blending seamlessly into the customer base, mystery shoppers gather objective and real-time feedback, offering businesses an invaluable perspective on the strengths and weaknesses of their operations.

This data-driven approach allows companies to make informed decisions, optimize processes, and enhance overall customer satisfaction, ensuring that every step of the customer journey aligns with their brand’s vision and objectives.

Evaluation of the Customer Journey

Mystery shoppers are given specific criteria and guidelines to observe and assess various touchpoints along the customer journey. Starting from the initial point of contact, such as the website or physical store entrance, they evaluate factors like the cleanliness of the premises, employee greeting, and overall ambiance.

As they progress through the customer journey, they observe product availability, staff knowledge, customer service quality, and how effectively upselling or cross-selling is done. Mystery shoppers pay attention to waiting times, queue management, and the checkout process.

Post-purchase, they may assess follow-up procedures, return policies, and the overall impression of their experience. This data provides valuable insights, enabling the organization to identify areas for improvement, enhance customer satisfaction, and optimize the entire customer journey.

Identify Gaps in Employee Training

Mystery shopping is a powerful tool for identifying gaps in employee training by simulating real customer interactions. Through this covert evaluation, mystery shoppers can assess how well employees demonstrate the skills and knowledge acquired during training.

They observe if employees are able to effectively handle customer inquiries, provide accurate information, and deliver exceptional customer service. Any discrepancies between the expected performance and the actual experience during mystery shopping highlight areas where employees may need further training or development. For example, if mystery shoppers encounter instances of poor product knowledge or unprofessional behavior, it signals potential gaps in training programs.

By capturing these insights, businesses can tailor their training initiatives to address specific weaknesses, ensuring employees are adequately prepared to meet customer expectations and enhance the overall customer experience.

Identify Areas of Improvement in Your Digital Experience

Mystery shopping plays a crucial role in identifying areas of improvement in a bank’s digital experience by leveraging trained evaluators who closely interact with the bank’s digital platforms.

These mystery shoppers conduct realistic simulations of customer journeys, exploring the bank’s website, mobile app, and online services. They assess the user-friendliness, efficiency, and effectiveness of each platform, paying attention to elements such as website navigation, mobile app functionality, online customer service responsiveness, and the overall ease of conducting transactions.

By observing real-time interactions, mystery shoppers uncover potential pain points, usability issues, and areas where the digital experience may fall short of customer expectations.

The data collected through mystery shopping provides invaluable insights, allowing the bank to pinpoint specific weaknesses and make data-driven decisions for enhancing their digital channels, ultimately delivering a seamless and satisfying customer experience.

What to Look For in Mystery Shopping Companies?

When a financial institution is considering hiring a mystery shopping company to assess its customer service and overall performance, several key factors should be taken into consideration. A poorly designed or implemented mystery shopping program can prove to be a wasted investment.

Here is a list of features a bank or credit union should look for in a first-class mystery shopping company:

1. Experience and Expertise

Choose a mystery shopping company with a proven track record of working with banks or financial institutions. Experience in the banking industry ensures that the mystery shopping program is tailored to the specific needs and challenges of the sector.

2. Customization

Look for a company that offers customizable mystery shopping programs. Every bank is unique, and the mystery shopping program should be designed to reflect the bank’s specific objectives and customer journey.

3. Range of Services

Ensure the mystery shopping company offers a comprehensive range of services, including in-person visits, phone calls, online interactions, and mobile app evaluations. This ensures that the entire customer experience across various channels is thoroughly assessed.

4. Pool of Mystery Shoppers

Inquire about the company’s database of mystery shoppers. A reliable company should have a diverse pool of shoppers who match the bank’s target customer demographics, ensuring that the assessments represent the bank’s actual customer base.

5. Training and Guidelines

Check if the mystery shopping company provides adequate training and clear guidelines to its shoppers. Properly trained shoppers are more likely to conduct accurate evaluations, leading to actionable insights.

6. Data Accuracy and Validation

Look for a company that has a robust data validation process to ensure accuracy and consistency in the collected data. This helps in obtaining reliable and objective feedback.

7. Reporting and Analytics

The mystery shopping company should provide detailed and insightful reports, with clear analytics and actionable recommendations. These reports help the bank identify areas for improvement and develop strategies for enhancing customer service.

8. Compliance and Ethics

Ensure that the mystery shopping company adheres to ethical practices, including obtaining informed consent from employees being evaluated. Additionally, make sure the company complies with relevant privacy laws and regulations.

9. Reputation and References

Research the mystery shopping company’s reputation by reading reviews and seeking references from other banks or businesses that have used their services. Positive reviews and references are indicators of a reliable and professional provider.

10. Cost-Effectiveness

While cost is a consideration, the focus should be on finding a reputable and effective mystery shopping company that provides value for money. Avoid compromising on quality for a lower price.

By carefully evaluating these factors, a financial institution can select a reputable mystery shopping company that aligns with its goals and helps improve customer service, employee performance, and overall customer satisfaction.

How Do Our Mystery Shoppers Work?

Other mystery shopping programs employ independent shoppers or even use untrained people from their own organization. Support EXP has an entire shopper engagement team that will invite, recruit, equip, train, coach, and develop your own customers to evaluate a real service experience based on the SERVQUAL dimensions of customer service and your own identified service standards.

Support EXP provides your customers with training resources, including an online Shopper Handbook, to prepare them to look for certain service behaviors while hiding their identity as an evaluator. A very engaged and educated customer evaluator pool is built and sustained.

Support EXP takes real customers and equips them, engages them and trains them to identify what their experience should sound like, look like, feel like. Then, the questions they answer are on specific, observable behaviors. That is key to the actionable feedback Support EXP’s clients receive: observable behaviors, not just impressions.

When these evaluators are deployed, they are not asked to score on a 1 to 5 scale. They are asked, what was your degree of satisfaction? And did you or did you not observe these particular behaviors?

None of the evaluators is subjective or ends up with some subjectivity to give a two or a one or a five. That is all determined, and that whole rating comes from the system that is calibrating the degree of satisfaction on each behavior and then providing the score.

Other mystery shop providers are putting the onus on the evaluators to come up with a number and a score. Support EXP handles that through the calibration of the data and the responses.

How Mystery Shopping Improves Customer Relationships

https://supportexp.com/solutions/customer-cx-mystery-shop-platform/

Mystery shopping can improve customer relationships in many ways. Mystery shopping helps businesses adopt a customer-centric approach by providing valuable insights into the customer experience. By understanding their customers’ perspective and pain points, businesses can make informed decisions to enhance their offerings and service.

Through mystery shopping evaluations, businesses can identify gaps in their customer service delivery. This data helps them recognize areas where employees might be falling short in meeting customer needs, allowing for targeted improvements.

Armed with the feedback from mystery shopping reports, businesses can implement targeted training and coaching programs to enhance the quality of customer service. This, in turn, leads to better customer interactions and relationships.

Mystery shopping helps businesses understand whether their offerings meet customer expectations. By addressing any discrepancies between customer expectations and actual experiences, businesses can build more trust with their clientele.

Mystery shopping can also highlight communication issues, both among employees and with customers. By improving communication, businesses can avoid misunderstandings and foster better relationships with their customers.

Mystery shopping provides an objective assessment of employee performance during customer interactions. By recognizing and rewarding excellent service, businesses can incentivize employees to maintain positive relationships with customers.

Mystery shoppers can evaluate how effectively employees identify and present upselling opportunities. By doing so in a customer-friendly manner, businesses can increase revenue while maintaining positive customer relationships. Similarly, mystery shopping can reveal how well employees handle customer complaints or concerns. By addressing any deficiencies in complaint resolution, businesses can strengthen their ability to turn negative experiences into positive ones.

Consistency is crucial in building strong customer relationships. Mystery shopping enables businesses to assess whether their customer service standards are consistently met across different locations and employees.

Finally, regular mystery shopping assessments allow businesses to track their progress in improving customer relationships over time. By analyzing trends and feedback, they can continuously refine their strategies to deliver an exceptional customer experience.

Ways That Mystery Shopping Improves Employee Training

https://supportexp.com/solutions/customer-cx-mystery-shop-platform/employee-training/

Mystery shopping can significantly improve employee training in many ways. Mystery shopping helps identify training needs by providing real-world feedback on employee performance during customer interactions.

By analyzing mystery shopping reports, businesses can identify specific areas where employees may need additional training or development. These areas could include product knowledge, customer service skills, handling complaints, upselling, or adherence to company policies and procedures.

Mystery shopping allows businesses to establish clear performance standards and expectations for their employees. By defining what constitutes excellent customer service and comparing it to actual experiences, organizations can set benchmarks for their staff to meet or exceed.

Unbiased and objective feedback from objective evaluators helps employees understand how their performance is perceived by real customers without fear of reprisal or bias from managers. The data gathered is used as a constructive coaching tool rather than a disciplinary measure.

With insights from mystery shopping reports, businesses can develop targeted training programs that address specific areas of improvement. Training sessions can be customized to focus on the most critical aspects of the customer experience, making the training more relevant and effective.

Mystery shopping programs can be used as a positive reinforcement tool. When employees receive positive feedback from mystery shoppers for their exceptional service, it boosts their morale and motivates them to maintain high-quality interactions with customers.

On the flip side, if employees receive feedback about areas where they need improvement, mystery shopping data can be used as a basis for corrective action. Employees can be provided with specific feedback and coaching to help them address any performance gaps.

Over time, by conducting regular mystery shopping evaluations, businesses can track the progress of their employees’ performance. This ongoing assessment allows them to measure the effectiveness of training initiatives and identify any recurring issues that need to be addressed.

Mystery shopping can help reinforce the company’s customer-centric culture and values. By evaluating how well employees embody these values during customer interactions, businesses can ensure consistency in delivering the desired customer experience.

Using Mystery Shopping to Improve Digital Brand Experiences

https://supportexp.com/solutions/customer-cx-mystery-shop-platform/digital-banking-shops/

In recent years, digital channels have become the channel of choice for banking customers. With the forced shift to digital channels at the onset of the COVID pandemic, many customers discovered the convenience of online or mobile banking, and now rely on it for day-to-day transactions.

Mystery shopping can be adapted to improve digital brand experiences in a number of ways:

1. Website Evaluation

Mystery shoppers can evaluate the usability and functionality of a brand’s website. They can assess how easy it is to navigate, search for products, and complete a purchase. This feedback helps identify any user experience issues that may hinder customer satisfaction.

2. Mobile App Assessment

If the brand has a mobile app, mystery shoppers can test its performance, functionality, and user-friendliness. This includes checking for any technical glitches, verifying if all features work correctly, and assessing how well the app aligns with the brand’s image.

3. Online Customer Service

Mystery shoppers can engage with the brand’s online customer service channels, such as live chat or email support, to evaluate response times, the quality of assistance provided, and the overall customer service experience in the digital realm.

4. Social Media Presence

Mystery shopping can involve monitoring the brand’s social media channels to assess how well they engage with customers, respond to queries or complaints, and maintain their brand image online.

5. Omnichannel Experience

Mystery shoppers can assess how well the brand maintains a consistent experience across different digital touchpoints, such as website, app, and social media. Ensuring a seamless omnichannel experience enhances brand trust and customer loyalty.

6. Checkout Process Evaluation

Mystery shoppers can evaluate the checkout process on the website or app to identify any potential friction points that may lead to cart abandonment. This helps businesses optimize the user journey and increase conversion rates.

7. Virtual Shopping Experience

For brands with virtual or augmented reality shopping options, mystery shoppers can assess the user-friendliness and effectiveness of these features.

8. Brand Reputation Online

Mystery shopping can include monitoring online reviews and feedback about the brand to identify any areas of improvement or concerns that need to be addressed.

9. Competitor Analysis

Mystery shopping can also involve comparing the brand’s digital experience with that of its competitors. This allows businesses to benchmark their performance and gain insights into industry best practices.

To instill customer loyalty that leads to retained, repeated and referred business, a financial institution must design and deliver frontline execution that meets its customers’ expectations. Insights from customer feedback analytics should promote frontline execution at a level that makes your organization stand out from the competition, with every experience, every customer, every time.

Support EXP has innovated a proven mystery shopping program for helping financial institutions of all sizes improve their frontline performance management to achieve the bottom-line results they want most.

Want to see how a first-class mystery shopping program can make a difference in both your frontline service and bottom-line results? Schedule a conversation with one of our analysts today!

Have More Questions? Reach Out to Our Team Of Experts

Net Promoter®, NPS®, NPS Prism®, and the NPS-related emoticons are registered trademarks of Bain & Company, Inc., Satmetrix Systems, Inc., and Fred Reichheld.